Frankly we would be better off with Chapter 11. The auto companies have been running on empty for a long time, draining their huge equity built up when they were the entire auto industry. With the sole exception of Ford, which is much more of an international auto company than the others, although it has made a few honest mistakes recently.
Ford would be just fine if it could get out from under its $80+ hourly labor costs. GM and Chrysler, however, are braindead, execs and unions both, and I see no way they can survive except as new companies with some of the old brand names, retaining some of the more advanced production facilities with new managers and workers.
There are other examples of the same problem, a king of corporate senility, in our economy - like Sears/Kmart, a failed grafting of failed discount/department store chains who long outlived their glory days, supported only by their real estate holdings.
For the US government to try to keep these zombie corporations going is like the taxpayers being chained to rotting corpses.